For more information, please contact the Box Office mobile line, at
239-784-1186
(Voice Messages left on the Box Office Phone will be returned within 24 hours)
Arts Center Theatre Box Office will Open to Walk Up ticket Purchases and Check In 30 Minutes Prior to each scheduled performance.
All Arts Center Theatre Productions will be at the theatre venue located in Marco Town Center
(next to Marco Brewery
Look for the Red Door )
1089 N Collier Blvd Suite #432
The Arts Center Theatre questions should be directed to the NEW Box Office number 239-784-1186 Monday-Friday 9am-4pm if you have questions that you need to be answered regarding a ticketed show (for that weekend) during the weekend you should direct them to the box office as they open a half hour before curtain for the weekend performances. (1089 N. Collier Blvd Suite #432)
Tickets for Mainstage productions are $35 Members and $40 Non-Members *unless otherwise noted on the event listing
2026-2027 Season
Individual Ticket Sales NOW Open

Packing Up Polly
November 5-22, 2026
By Leslie Kimbell
Directed by Hyla Crane
Polly Porter, famous 1970’s gospel singer of the group POLLY PORTER & THE PRAISE HIS NAME SINGERS, has gone on up to heaven. Her daughter, Caroline, has come home to Savannah, Georgia, to pack up Miss Polly’s house but there is just one little problem (or two or three): Miss Polly was an extreme hoarder of epic proportions, Caroline’s useless siblings are totally MIA, and her three best friends from high school, former co-cheerleaders, have all shown up…UNANNOUNCED! Lizzy now owns the Miss Georgia Belle Pageantry system, Donna Jo is the local community theatre diva, and Becca is having a late in life geriatric pregnancy with baby girl number five. The gospel music plays and the margaritas pour as the four ladies laugh, cry, scream, and COME TOGTHER to pack up Miss Polly’s house, heal old wounds, and make new plans for their future.

FLOAT
December 9-20, 2026
By Patricia Kane
Directed by Amy Saad
The industrious members of the Budapest Women’s Club (pronounced Bu-DAP-est) come together for an annual tradition: the crafting of the holiday parade float. But under the surface of this pleasant gathering, the women find themselves grappling with sexuality, betrayal, and their own hard and fast notions of right and wrong. In this ode to the complicated undercurrents of Midwestern morality, you’ll meet Marty, Luce, Char, Arletta, and Doodee — five women who face the tests life presents to them with laughter, love, and a lot of fake snow.

Death Trap
by Ira Levin
Directed by Paula Keenan
January 7-24, 2027
Seemingly comfortable in his charming Connecticut home, Sidney Bruhl, a successful writer of Broadway thrillers, is struggling to overcome a string of recent failures and a shortage of funds. When a student in his writing seminar sends him a new script – a thriller that Sidney recognizes immediately as a potential Broadway hit – Sidney sees an opportunity. With his wife’s help, he devises a plan to “collaborate” with the student, an idea which the younger man quickly accepts. Suspense mounts steadily as the plot begins to twist and turn with devilish cleverness that builds to a still-startling finale.
Deathtrap premiered on Broadway at the Music Box Theatre on February 26, 1978. Directed by Robert Moore, the production featured John Wood, Victor Garber, Marian Seldes, Marian Winters and Richard Woods. A 1982 film adaptation starred Michael Caine, Christopher Reeve and Dyan Cannon.

The Red Velvet Cake Wars
February 4-21, 2027
By Jessie Jones, Nicholas Hope and Jamie Wooten
Directed by Cheryl Duggan
In this riotously funny comedy, the three Verdeen cousins could not have picked a worse time to throw their family reunion, their outrageous antics delighting local gossips in the small town of Sweetgum.
Having “accidentally” crashed her minivan through the bedroom wall of her husband’s girlfriend’s doublewide, Gaynelle is one frazzled nerve away from a meltdown. Peaches is struggling to decide if it’s time to have her long-absent trucker husband declared dead and Jimmie Wyvette is resorting to extreme measures win the affections of Sweetgum’s newest widower. The cousins can’t back out of the reunion now, it’s on and Gaynelle’s hosting it. As this fast-paced romp barrels on, the audience will wish their own family reunions were this fun!

Peter Fogel’s New Boomer Humor Tour
(A Comedy Tribute to the 60s & 70s)
Still Rockin as Long as I am in Bed by 9:00 PM
One Day Only – February 15, 2027 2 PM and 6 PM
Award-winning Actor/Comedian Peter J. Fogel (Star of the one-man show Til Death Do Us Part. You First!) is back with his newest one-man stand-up comedy show, STILL ROCKIN’. As Long as I’m in Bed by 9 PM!
A hysterical mix of stand-up, storytelling, and boomer-approved humor, Fogel takes audiences on a laugh-filled journey through the trials of aging while proving you can still “rock” – even if you’re in a recliner.
With razor-sharp wit and relatable observations, Fogel explores everything from the mysteries of modern technology to the aches and pains of middle age, reminding audiences that life’s punch lines keep getting better with age. His high-energy performance has been delighting crowds nationwide, leaving them nodding in recognition and doubled over in laughter.
In the 60’s and 70’s — we had rotary phones, leisure suits, GI-Joe action figures, 8-tracks, and we even rode bikes without Helmets. Yes, Baby Boomers survived the ’60s and ’70s without GPSs, voicemail, and texting! From the trials and tribulations of modern technology to the aches and pains that arrive uninvited- to getting your AARP discount, Fogel mines comedy gold from everyday moments of middle age and beyond!
AN ALL BABY-BOOMER – NON MILLENIAL COMEDY SHOW!

Sandbag, Stage Left (Or, One Dead Dolly)
March 4-21, 2027
Directed by Marlene Strollo
The members of the Mill City Players are besides themselves over the mysterious death of their leading lady, Amelia Meddle, who during a performance, was cruelly squashed by a flying sandbag. All fingers point to her husband, undertaker Arnold Meddle, who was seen wandering around backstage just before the sailing sandbag hit pay dirt. It’s mud-slinging galore between Defense lawyer Philip Static and Prosecutor Emily Cling. Meanwhile, one by one the members of the Mill City players take the stand to implicate Arnold Meddle knowing about his jealous nature and Amelia’s flirtations with Mill City lead actor Byron Shelley. This, claims the Prosecution, provides Arnold with his motive. But Arnold contends he is innocent, but who could crush such a lovely woman under a pile of dirt and burlap? Mill City Stage Manager Gretel Van Cistern? Sexy actress Shelley Shelley? Arnold’s mousy Assistant Embalmer Margaret “Chuck”� Bury? Or Medical Examiner Salvatore Soo, whom, we discover in a startling revelation, is related to the manufacturer of the deadly sandbag? It’s the case of the century, (or at least this past week), under the steady gavel of female Judge Royale Been, who presides over a jury of audience members, called for duty when the Judge dismisses the original jury for not inviting her to their party.
Author takes no responsibility for personal injury which may occur when audience members roll in the aisles with laughter.
Sandbag, Stage Left is a parody of serious courtroom dramas such as Witness for the Prosecution, Twelve Angry Men and Night of January 16th.

Ben Hur (an epic comedy)
April 1-18, 2027
Directed by Joan Gerberding
The story follows an amateur theatre troupe as they produce the massive tale of the fictional Jewish prince and merchant Judah Ben-Hur. He falls to galley slave and rises to champion charioteer within Jerusalem during the life of Jesus Christ, while the actors struggle along through the piece as rivalries form and offstage romances interfere. Complete with chariot race, sea battle, and stage combat, Patrick Barlow weaves his compressed style popularized by The 39 Steps into one of the largest stories ever told.
Please note:
Due to the nature of theatrical bookings, titles, seating chart, schedules and pricing subject to change.
Subscription tickets are nonrefundable. Subscription tickets may be exchanged once during the run of each production.
All tickets are non-refundable. Non-subscription tickets may be exchanged for a $5 surcharge. (see Ticket Exchange Policy)
A $5.00 venue restoration fee is included in the ticket price.
Arts Center Theatre Ticket Exchange Policy (Theatrical Productions Only)
Ticket Exchanges: Tickets may be exchanged, based on availabilty by calling the Box Office at 239-784-1186 or during box office business hours which take place 90 minutes before the start of each performance. A fee of $5.00 will be charged per ticket (subscribers receive free exchanges). Exchanges will be accommodated up to 48 hours in advance of each performance.
If an exchange is for a higher-priced ticket, you are responsible for the additional cost. If an exchange is for a lower-priced ticket.
Ticket Returns: If you are unable to make a performance and are unable to exchange them, you can return them to the box office and can claim the return as a tax-deductible donation.
Refunds are only available if the theater cancels the performance for which the patron holds tickets; tickets to postponed performances may be exchanged for another date or for a credit. Service fees are non-refundable.
All ticket sales purchased online are subject to a transaction fee.
All prices and shows are subject to change.
ALL TICKETS SALES ARE FINAL. THERE ARE NO REFUNDS OR CREDITS GIVEN FOR MISSED PERFORMANCES
Marco Island Center for the Arts Membership
When you purchase any Marco Island Center for the Arts membership level, you will receive $5 off the ticket price of all 2026-2027 Mainstage productions. Learn more about membership HERE.